Skip to content 
Some roof damage, like a tree falling through into your living room, is hard to miss. But hail damage is rarely that obvious.
After a severe storm, your roof might look perfectly fine from the driveway. But with a closer look, you might find cracked shingles and missing granules. In other cases, you might see clear signs of damage, such as dark impact marks or big dents in nearby gutters, downspouts, and metal surfaces.
Because hail damage doesn’t always cause immediate leaks, it’s easy to miss the problem until months later. By then, the roof might already be suffering from some pretty serious issues.
Michigan sees its fair share of severe storms each year, including many that bring hail. In fact, there were at least 69 hail events between June of 2025 and June of 2026, according to HailTrace.
So, it’s important for Michigan-area homeowners to know what hail damage looks like. That way, you will have a better idea of whether it’s time to schedule a professional inspection.
Common Signs of Hail Damage on Asphalt Shingles
Asphalt shingles are the most widely used roofing material in Michigan. When a hailstorm rolls in, they’re one of the materials most frequently damaged. The exact appearance of the damage can vary a bit based on the size of the hailstones and the age of your roof, but there are a few signs we often look for during an inspection.
Just understand that these signs don’t necessarily mean your roof needs to be replaced. Sometimes, all it takes is a targeted repair to get your roof working at its best again. The key is to identify the damage before it has time to snowball into a bigger issue.
Bruised Shingles
When hail strikes a shingle with enough force, it can damage the material beneath the surface without actually breaking through it. These damaged areas often feel soft or spongy to the touch and may resemble a bruise on a piece of fruit.
Bruising isn’t always visible from the ground, which makes it tough to identify. Though the shingle may still look intact, the bruised areas are weaker and may deteriorate faster than the surrounding shingles.
Granule Loss
The coarse granules coating asphalt shingles serve a few important purposes. They protect the underlying asphalt from UV exposure, improve fire resistance, and slow weather-related deterioration.
Hail can knock those granules loose, leaving behind bare patches across your roof. When this happens, you might notice an abnormal amount of granules collecting in your gutters or downspouts.
While some granule loss is normal as shingles age, concentrated bare spots after a hailstorm usually indicate impact damage.
Dark Impact Marks
Dark impact marks usually appear when hail strips enough granules to expose the darker asphalt underneath. The spots may vary in size and usually appear randomly across the roof rather than in a uniform pattern.
These marks don’t automatically equal a roof replacement, but they do tell you that your shingles have lost some of their protective surface layer.
Cracked Shingles
If a hailstone is big enough, it can completely crack an asphalt shingle.
Some cracks are immediately obvious after a storm, but sometimes, they take a few months of natural expansion and contraction to show. Once a shingle cracks, water has a much easier path into the roofing system.
Exposed Roofing Mat
In more severe storms, hail can batter your roof enough to expose the roofing mat beneath the granules. This type of damage leaves shingles far more vulnerable to UV degradation and moisture intrusion. It can also accelerate the aging process and shorten the roof’s overall lifespan.
Because exposed mat damage often signals a substantial loss of protection, spotting this kind of damage means it’s time to give our team a call to inspect the full extent of the damage.
Loose Shingles
When a hailstorm rolls in, it’s usually accompanied by stiff winds. So, after a storm, look for shingles that appear to have fallen victim to the wind. This includes shingles that appear out of alignment, partially lifted, or curled at the edges, as well as any that are completely missing.
Loose or missing shingles are definitely a problem, as they may allow water to work its way underneath the roofing system in future storms.
| Sign | What It Looks Like | Why It Matters |
| Bruised shingles | Soft spots beneath the shingle surface | May weaken the shingle and shorten its lifespan |
| Granule loss | Bare patches or granules in the gutters | Leaves shingles more vulnerable to UV damage |
| Dark impact marks | Random dark spots across the roof | Often indicate hail impacts and granule loss |
| Cracked shingles | Visible fractures or splits | Can allow water to penetrate the roof system |
| Exposed roofing mat | Underlying roof material becomes visible | Accelerates deterioration and increases leak risk |
| Loose shingles | Shingles appear lifted or displaced | May allow water intrusion |
What Hail Damage Looks Like on Other Roofing Materials
Not every home in Michigan is made of asphalt shingles, and hail can damage virtually any type of roof. The exact signs depend on the material, but when we inspect these materials for hail damage, this is what we look for.
| Roof Material | Look For |
| Metal roofing | Dents in roof panels, flashing, or ridge caps; scratches or damage to protective coatings |
| Clay or concrete tile | Cracked tiles, chipped edges, broken sections, tile fragments on the ground |
| Wood shake roofing | Splits, cracks, punctures, impact marks, broken shake corners and edges |
Much like damage to asphalt shingles, the severity of the damage to these materials depends on the size of the hailstones and the condition and age of the roof. If you see any of these signs, it’s a good idea to schedule a professional inspection.
Signs of Hail Damage Around Your Property
Spotting hail damage on a roof can be pretty tough to do from the ground, but it’s always best to leave roof-top inspections to the pros. So, instead of clambering onto the roof to get a closer look, walk around your property and look for signs of damage elsewhere.
If the hail was large enough to damage screens, dent metal surfaces, or leave impact marks around your home, there’s a good chance your roof took some damage too. Here are a few areas to check:
| Area | Signs to look for |
| Gutters and downspouts | Dings, dents, scratches, or chipped paint |
| Siding | Cracks, chips, punctures, or impact marks |
| Window screens | Tears, holes, or stretched mesh |
| Outdoor AC units | Bent or dented condenser fins |
| Garage doors | Dents or impact marks on metal surfaces |
| Mailboxes | Dings, dents, or chipped paint |
| Decks and fences | Fresh impact marks, chips, or splintering |
| Outdoor furniture | Dents, cracks, or visible storm damage |
Hail Damage vs. Normal Roof Wear
Hail isn’t to blame for every roofing issue. Sometimes, damage is just the culmination of normal wear and tear.
Roofing materials naturally age over time. Years of exposure to sunlight, rain, snow, temperature swings, and everyday weather gradually wear them down. Because some of these signs can resemble storm damage, it’s not always easy to tell which is which.
One of the biggest distinctions is the pattern of the damage. Hail damage typically appears as isolated impact marks scattered across the roof, while normal wear tends to occur more uniformly.
| Hail Damage | Normal Roof Wear |
| Random impact marks across the roof | Consistent aging across large sections |
| Circular bruises or soft spots | Gradual loss of flexibility over time |
| Sudden granule loss after a storm | Slow, even granule loss over many years |
| Cracked shingles caused by impacts | Curling, cupping, or brittleness due to age |
| Damage concentrated on one side of the roof | Similar wear patterns across multiple roof slopes |
If the damage doesn’t look completely consistent with one or the other, a professional inspection can provide a clear answer.
Hail Damage & Roof Replacement: How Much Damage Is Too Much Damage?
Hail damage generally needs to be quite extensive to warrant a replacement.
If the hail damage is minor, with only a few affected shingles here and there, repairs are usually the practical solution. If the damage is widespread and severe, a replacement might make more sense.
When evaluating a roof to determine repair or replacement, we look at:
- The number of damaged shingles
- The severity of the damage
- Whether the damage is cosmetic or functional
- The age of the roof
- The availability of matching replacement shingles
- Insurance requirements and coverage considerations
For example, let’s say Roof A has minor granule loss with only about a dozen damaged shingles. In this case, we would likely replace those damaged shingles, and the roof would be good to go.
Roof B, on the other hand, has bruising, cracking, and exposed roofing mat scattered across the roof, affecting multiple roof slopes. It’s also an older roof that’s getting close to retirement, too. In this situation, we may recommend a replacement roof.
The only sure way to say which is the best option is to have a professional inspection done. During these, we can assess the extent of the damage to determine which option makes the most sense for your home.
What to Do If You Suspect Hail Damage
If you think your roof might’ve been damaged during a recent storm, here’s what you can do to help figure out what the next step is:
- Check gutters, siding, window screens, outdoor HVAC equipment, and other exterior surfaces for signs of hail impacts.
- Inspect ceilings, walls, and attic spaces for water stains, discoloration, or other moisture that could indicate a leak.
- Schedule a professional roof inspection to identify damage that might not be easy to see from the ground.
- Review your insurance coverage if the inspection reveals storm damage to see what’s included.
How Much Does Hail Damage Roof Repair Cost?
Repairing hail damage to a roof can cost anywhere from $150 to $12,500 or more. That range varies drastically because every roof is different. Factors that play into the cost include:
- The size of the damaged area
- Whether flashing, vents, or other roof components were damaged
- The age and condition of the roof
- The availability of matching roof materials
- Whether repairs can be completed or replacement is necessary
Material is a big contributor here. An asphalt shingled roof costs anywhere from $4 to $15 per square foot to repair, whereas a slate roof can cost $5 to $30 per square foot to repair.
When we find damage that needs repair after a hailstorm, we always provide a detailed quote. That way, you know what to expect cost-wise from the necessary repairs.
Frequently Asked Questions About Roof Hail Damage
Even after identifying signs of hail damage, many homeowners still have questions about what happens next. We’ve answered some of the most common ones below.
How can you tell if your roof has been damaged by hail?
Look for signs like bruised shingles, missing granules, cracked shingles, and dents on nearby gutters or metal surfaces. It’s not always easy to see hail damage from the ground, so if you’re not sure, it’s a good idea to book a professional roof inspection.
How long does a roof last after hail damage?
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer for roof lifespan. Some roofs keep working well for years after minor hail damage. Others begin deteriorating faster, especially if the damage goes unnoticed for a while. The severity of the damage and the roof’s age and condition will determine how long it holds up after hail damage.
Does insurance pay for hail damage to a roof?
In many cases, insurance does pay for hail damage to a roof, though it varies by policy. For example, Progressive states that most standard home insurance policies cover hail damage minus your deductible. If you’re not sure whether your policy covers it, talk to your insurance agent.
Should I replace my roof after hail damage?
Not necessarily. Hail damage is often repairable when the damage is minor to moderate. Replacement is typically only recommended when the damage is widespread, repairs are no longer practical, or the roof is already almost at the end of its lifespan.
Is hail damage always visible?
Nope. Some types of hail damage, such as bruising beneath the surface of a shingle, are tough to see without a close look. A roof can be damaged even if it looks pretty normal from the ground.
Can hail damage a roof without causing leaks?
It can. Hail can weaken shingles, remove protective granules, and even create little cracks that don’t leak right away. Sometimes, leaks don’t start becoming obvious until months after the storm.
Can you inspect a roof for hail damage yourself?
For safety reasons, it’s best to avoid climbing onto the roof yourself to look for damage. You can walk around your property to look for other signs that can point to roof damage, but actually inspecting the roof close-up is a job best left to the professionals.
Count on Schoenherr Roofing for Hail Damage Inspections and Repairs
If your roof was recently exposed to hail, a professional inspection can help determine whether repairs are needed and identify damage that might not be easy to see from the ground.
For more than 30 years, Schoenherr Roofing has helped Michigan homeowners repair storm damage and protect their homes from future roofing problems. Our team can evaluate your roof, explain our findings, and recommend the most appropriate solution based on the condition of your roofing system.
Whether you need a minor repair or more extensive storm damage restoration, we’re here to help. Contact us today at (616) 282-1783 to schedule an inspection.
Sources & References
- Angi – “How Much Does Hail Damage Roof Repair Cost?”
Provides national hail damage repair cost estimates, including typical price ranges, inspection costs, and factors that influence the cost of repairing storm-damaged roofs.
https://www.angi.com/articles/how-much-repair-roof-hail-damage-cost.htm - HailTrace – “Michigan Hail Maps & Storm Tracking Data”
An industry-focused, meteorological tracking database providing real-time and historical hail swath maps, wind data, and severe weather impact analysis across Michigan counties. The platform tracks specific storm paths and calculates structural damage footprints to assist roofing contractors, restoration professionals, and insurance adjusters with property impact assessments.
https://hailtrace.com/hail-maps/state/michigan - Progressive – “Does Home Insurance Cover Storm Damage?”
Explains how homeowners insurance policies typically handle storm-related damage, including common coverage considerations, exclusions, deductibles, and the claims process after severe weather events.
https://www.progressive.com/answers/does-home-insurance-cover-storm-damage
