...
(248) 422-2910 Get A Free Estimate
Schedule Call Now Get A Quote

Residential Roofing – Pros & Cons of a Shingle Roof

Residential Roofing Pros & Cons of a Shingle Roof Schoenherr

Table of Contents

The most common type of roofing for residential homes is Asphalt Shingles. There are many reasons why asphalt shingles are so popular, including ease of replacement too low material costs.

Before you go ahead and choose asphalt shingles, there are a few things to consider. Every roofing material has its pros and cons to look at before you make a big investment in your home. Your home is an asset, and being aware of your roofing could potentially save you money in the long run.

Pros of Asphalt Shingles

  • Asphalt Shingles are readily available at an affordable price.
  • Easy to remove and install. (keeps your costs lower)
  • Very versatile shingle that adapts well to many applications.
  • Great for steep roofing.
  • Do not require special edging, wall terminations, vent flushings, chimneys, and more. (simple and easy)
  • Low Maintenance.
  • Durable to the elements.
  • Can be walked on without damaging.
  • Lightweight and strong.
  • Fit most Residential roofing systems
  • Come in a variety of prices, colors, and sizes depending on the application.
  • Fire Protection (for certain brands/types, ask a specialist)
  • Repairs are relatively easy to do with Asphalt Shingles.

Cons of Asphalt Shingles

  • Prone to wind damage – High winds can cause your shingles to be lifted from the rooftop and torn and damaged.
  • Depending on color, Asphalt shingles can transfer solar heat to your home. They can also be damaged by too much heat, leading to the need for restoration or repair.
  • Mold & Mildew – This is caused by excessive moisture or pooling in the shaded areas of your roof. This can damage shingles and underlayment, causing leaks.
  • There are different types and qualities of shingles, but the Asphalt type roofs are long-lasting, anywhere from 15-30 years
Durable Cost Effective Residential Roofing Pros & Cons of a Shingle Roof Schoenherr

Hiring a Contractor Who Does it Right

If you are in need of a new roof, you are in need of an expert roofing contractor who will get the job done right the first time and not take any shortcuts.

An asphalt shingle roof is a great way to go for longevity, cost-saving, ease of installation & repair, and versatility. Color, size, and lack of need for extra hardware also make these an attractive offer.

Hire a contractor who will give you an honest evaluation to start. You don’t want to be sold a roof, you want to buy a roof because you need one. Your money is important to you, so don’t be swindled by a smooth pitch. Check for quality and workmanship guarantees as well as possible warranties. Finally, don’t get hung up on price. A roof is a long-term investment for your home. Spend a little more now to ensure you’re getting the best roof possible for your buck.

Other Options to Consider

Asphalt shingle roofing is by far the most popular style of roofing for residential roofing. Depending on where you live, the type of climate and type of weather you get, and the sun exposure, you may want to look at different options.

Options may vary depending on supplies and availability, and even on the contractor’s ability. Other options include, but are not limited to: TPO, Metal Roofing, Rubber Slate, Green Roofs, and even Cement. There are other options, but these are the most popular.

As always, check with your local contractor first, go over your options, and invest in your future with the knowledge to make the right choices.

Schoenherr Roofing: Michigan’s Preferred Roofing Contractors

Whether you think shingles are the right choice for your new roof, or you want to explore other options, the professionals at Schoenherr Roofing are ready to help! We provide a full line of residential and commercial roofing services, and we can even help with your gutter, insulation, and siding needs.

Contact us today to schedule your free estimate and see the Schoenherr Roofing difference yourself!

Share the post:

Related Articles

Table of Contents

Financing Questions?

Schoenherr Roofing Can Help Answer Them!
Meet The Author

Looking For A Roofer In Your Area?

Call Schoenherr Roofing For The Best Local Roofing Service

Latest Updates From Schoenherr

All reviews
Google
Google
Angie's List
Angie's List
Home Advisor
Home Advisor
ExcellentTrustindex star 1Trustindex star 2Trustindex star 3Trustindex star 4Trustindex star 54.81484 reviews
4.8Trustindex star 1Trustindex star 2Trustindex star 3Trustindex star 4Trustindex star 5
Excellent1484 reviews
ExcellentGoogle star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 54.81403 reviews
4.8Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Excellent1403 reviews
GoodAngiesList star 1AngiesList star 2AngiesList star 3AngiesList star 4AngiesList star 53.621 reviews
3.6AngiesList star 1AngiesList star 2AngiesList star 3AngiesList star 4AngiesList star 5
Good21 reviews
ExcellentHomeAdvisor star 1HomeAdvisor star 2HomeAdvisor star 3HomeAdvisor star 4HomeAdvisor star 54.760 reviews
4.7HomeAdvisor star 1HomeAdvisor star 2HomeAdvisor star 3HomeAdvisor star 4HomeAdvisor star 5
Excellent60 reviews
Posted on Google Google
Lawrence Gursten profile picture
Lawrence Gursten
2 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I replaced my 30 year old roof. I found Schoenherr Roofing and it was a very professional and friendly experience. From the initial representative,Nathanial, to pick out our roof to Noah,heading everything in putting on the roof and gutters,it was a pleasure dealing with them. I highly recommend all to use Schoenherr in getting your roof excellently replaced.
Posted on Google Google
Sue Harrington profile picture
Sue Harrington
2 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
There were some hiccups in communication, but the job got done to our satisfaction. I am confident that we have a nice roof. We will need a new, more powerful bathroom exhaust fan now, because ours is not strong enough to vent efficiently through the new venting they installed. It worked fine before, but the venting was not up to code. This caused some upset, but Kyle did a good job explaining the issue.
Posted on Google Google
Kayla Karaszewski profile picture
Kayla Karaszewski
3 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Just wow. Every step of the process of working with Schoenherr roofing was great. I honestly have no complaints whatsoever. I would say communication is their strongest skill. We were kept up to date with every step of our project and all of our questions were answered as they came up. It’s clear there is a strong teamwork dynamic at this company and it shows—everyone was friendly and so professional, in my opinion it made their work even better. I guess I’m at the age where a new roof and attic insulation is the most exciting part of my Friday night. But it’s true, they did an exceptional job and I’m a little sad that we won’t need a new roof for another 25 years because that means we don’t get to work with this company again. Thanks to Ed and Leo, Chad, Luis and the roofing crew, and Kyle and the insulation crew for an amazing job.
Posted on Google Google
Crystal Keat profile picture
Crystal Keat
4 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Steve was an amazing guy! He was at a family members house last week, and he was a great person. He explained what he was doing, he even showed pictures of what he fixed before and after. He was very knowledgeable and professional.
Posted on Google Google
Robert Weir profile picture
Robert Weir
5 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
The roof replacement at our residence was performed in a very timely and professional manner. Workers as well as material showed up on time and a complete cleanup was performed when complete.
Posted on Google Google
Liz MacGIllis profile picture
Liz MacGIllis
6 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
My sales experience was excellent, fair discounts and no pressure. Jeff was professional and knowledgeable. My crew was amazing. Alex was the foreman and did over and above. Each crew person was assigned their areas and were focused. I have gutter filters and was concerned about potential damage, no damage they handled with care. Cleanup was great. Only found one nail on the window sil, obviously a traveler..lol. Even the dumpster guy moved it and raked for nails. Thank you again. Highly recommend.
Posted on Google Google
Laurie Lennon Hynes profile picture
Laurie Lennon Hynes
9 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Leo the initial salesman was outstanding.Excellent, organized and complete presentation with wonderful demonstration of materials. Josh Project Manager was exemplary. His love of the company and ability to connect with us was over and above what is expected. He is truly a remarkable employee.
Posted on Google Google
Ann Walker profile picture
Ann Walker
9 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
The Schoenherr contractor Dwayne, came on time, and did a wonderful job for me at a critical time. Very professional and courteous, I highly recommend him and this company!
Posted on Google Google
Meghan Mullen profile picture
Meghan Mullen
9 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Our project manager Chad was outstanding and professional with great follow up communications. Roofing team was excellent, and did a great job cleaning up after. 2 minor issues resolved immediately. Would definitely recommend them.
Posted on Google Google
Gerhard Schroter profile picture
Gerhard Schroter
10 days ago
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Responsive, thorough and customer oriented team from initial contact through work completion and final inspection. Very competitive pricing and thorough ini initial inspection and project consultation (Ben). Very flexible scheduling especially to accommodate solar panel de/re-installation. Dedicated customer-oriented PM to synch and manage the project (Chad). Job site team (Louis) was professional, courteous and quality focused - job completed in 1 day. Thank you to the entire Schoenherr roofing team!
Posted on Home Advisor Home Advisor
Ksthy P. profile picture
Ksthy P.
26 days ago
HomeAdvisor star 1HomeAdvisor star 2HomeAdvisor star 3HomeAdvisor star 4HomeAdvisor star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Home Advisor.
Blake was a wonderful and thorough sales job! Chad was on top of everything there after. The roofing crew were courteous and cleaned up well afterwards. It was a 5 star job from start to finish.
Posted on Angie's List Angie's List
Tammy G. profile picture
Tammy G.
29 days ago
AngiesList star 1AngiesList star 2AngiesList star 3AngiesList star 4AngiesList star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Angie's List.
My experience went smoothly right out the gate.from scheduling a quote (Nate), signing contract, delivery of materials, communication with my project manager (Dan), and seeing jose and his crew work with detail/care. I made the absolute right choice in this company. Their mission statement is spot on! Thank you very much.
Posted on Angie's List Angie's List
Laura V. profile picture
Laura V.
45 days ago
AngiesList star 1AngiesList star 2AngiesList star 3AngiesList star 4AngiesList star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Angie's List.
Schoenherr Roofing did a complete roof replacement on our house: 2,800 s.f. Colonial, 39 “squares,” in Troy, which was finished, on time, in 1.5 days. From the materials delivery company, to the project manager’s (PM) pre-job contacts, to the on-site workers, everyone was friendly, helpful, and easy to deal with. Although the noise WAS horrific, we knew it would be!! The finished roof looks awesome. The PM did a post-job inspection the next day to address any remaining nails on the ground (not many), and picked up excess materials not used. We are extremely satisfied with Schoenherr Roofing and would highly recommend them for a total roof replacement!
Posted on Home Advisor Home Advisor
Marcy P. profile picture
Marcy P.
100 days ago
HomeAdvisor star 1HomeAdvisor star 2HomeAdvisor star 3HomeAdvisor star 4HomeAdvisor star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Home Advisor.
So pleased with workers and the company. Wonderful work done and explained everything. Cleaned up after.
Posted on Angie's List Angie's List
Antoinette D. profile picture
Antoinette D.
212 days ago
AngiesList star 1AngiesList star 2AngiesList star 3AngiesList star 4AngiesList star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Angie's List.
Overall, we had a positive experience with our roof replacement, but a few issues kept it from being excellent. Scheduling was easy, the consultant was on time and prepared, and the quote and financing options were competitive. The crew arrived on time, worked efficiently, and completed the roof quickly, even with two existing layers to remove. We also appreciated the progress photos and prompt follow-up with the invoice, financing paperwork, and final inspection scheduling. Our main concerns were communication, cleanup, and safety. We did not receive a response when we asked for a dumpster delivery time, which made planning garage access difficult. We were also told the generator and A/C units would be covered, but they were not. We also observed that no one working on the roof appeared to be using fall protection, which was concerning for work over 6 feet. The roof itself appears to have been installed efficiently and professionally.
Posted on Angie's List Angie's List
Jay D. profile picture
Jay D.
222 days ago
AngiesList star 1AngiesList star 2AngiesList star 3AngiesList star 4AngiesList star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Angie's List.
I had Dustin install a bathroom vent out the roof. He was efficient and very professional, nice job!
Posted on Angie's List Angie's List
Anthony V. profile picture
Anthony V.
292 days ago
AngiesList star 1AngiesList star 2AngiesList star 3AngiesList star 4AngiesList star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Angie's List.
We recently had our roof replaced and I pleased to report that Schoenherr Roofing Company delivered a five-star performance. from the initial call with Amanda to schedule a meeting with Joe ,who thoroughly explained the entire process to my wife and me, the experience was seamless . Additionally, Korey, the project manager, kept us informed throughout the process providing regular updates,photos,and addressing all our questions. we will undoubtedly utilize their services again in the future for our siding needs. Schoenherr Roofing Company is a truly a great company to work with Anthony Vinson Sr
Posted on Angie's List Angie's List
Steve J. profile picture
Steve J.
333 days ago
AngiesList star 1AngiesList star 2AngiesList star 3AngiesList star 4AngiesList star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Angie's List.
Caleb was our salesperson, I was so impressed how he worked with our insurance company to make sure our claim went through properly. Chad was our project manager, he did a great Job communicating how the process would go before during and after the installation. Very impressed!
Posted on Angie's List Angie's List
Glenda G. profile picture
Glenda G.
403 days ago
AngiesList star 1AngiesList star 2AngiesList star 3AngiesList star 4AngiesList star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Angie's List.
Great job and Quality products.
Posted on Angie's List Angie's List
Jason S. profile picture
Jason S.
429 days ago
AngiesList star 1AngiesList star 2AngiesList star 3AngiesList star 4AngiesList star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Angie's List.
I had Schoenherr Roofing out for a 5 year inspection and was extremely pleased with their tech Dustin . Polite , knowledgeable, hard worker and took pictures of all his work so I could verify the fixes . Overall a great experience!
Posted on Home Advisor Home Advisor
Tiffany R profile picture
Tiffany R
627 days ago
HomeAdvisor star 1HomeAdvisor star 2HomeAdvisor star 3HomeAdvisor star 4HomeAdvisor star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Home Advisor.
Wonderful company with true value in their work. The employees, both in office and on-site, are very professional and provide quality service.
Posted on Angie's List Angie's List
Matthew M. profile picture
Matthew M.
730 days ago
AngiesList star 1AngiesList star 2AngiesList star 3AngiesList star 4AngiesList star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Angie's List.
Absolutely thrilled with the work done by Schoenherr Roofing! I had been struggling with a leaking roof for a while, and after several failed attempts by other contractors, I finally found someone who not only diagnosed the problem but fixed it with precision and professionalism. The issue turned out to be the chimney area, and instead of just patching things up, Caleb took the time to build a cricket around the chimney to divert water and prevent future leaks. The craftsmanship is top-notch, and the work was completed efficiently without any mess or disruption to my daily routine. What really stood out was their clear communication and dedication to making sure everything was done right. They explained the entire process, answered all my questions, and took care to ensure that the repair would provide a long-lasting solution. Since the repair, I’ve had no further issues, even during heavy rainstorms. I can finally rest easy knowing my roof is in great shape! I highly recommend Schoenherr Roofing for anyone in need of roofing services—they are skilled, reliable, and genuinely care about doing the job right. Thank you Caleb for saving my home from further damage!
Posted on Home Advisor Home Advisor
Chris S profile picture
Chris S
892 days ago
HomeAdvisor star 1HomeAdvisor star 2HomeAdvisor star 3HomeAdvisor star 4HomeAdvisor star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Home Advisor.
Install or Replace an Asphalt Shingle Roof Thanks to Nick our salesman, and the whole team who were all very Professional. We were very satisfied with the whole job and clean-up. We would recommend Schoenherr Roofing to anyone. Chris S. Romeo
Posted on Home Advisor Home Advisor
Chris S profile picture
Chris S
892 days ago
HomeAdvisor star 1HomeAdvisor star 2HomeAdvisor star 3HomeAdvisor star 4HomeAdvisor star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Home Advisor.
Install or Replace an Asphalt Shingle Roof Thanks to Nick our salesman, and the whole team who were all very Professional. We were very satisfied with the whole job and clean-up. We would recommend Schoenherr Roofing to anyone. Chris S. Romeo
Posted on Home Advisor Home Advisor
Chelsea P profile picture
Chelsea P
919 days ago
HomeAdvisor star 1HomeAdvisor star 2HomeAdvisor star 3HomeAdvisor star 4HomeAdvisor star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Home Advisor.
Install or Replace an Asphalt Shingle Roof An extremely professional operation who did a quick, efficient and high quality job of my large new roof. I would recommend this company to anyone.
Posted on Home Advisor Home Advisor
Chelsea P profile picture
Chelsea P
919 days ago
HomeAdvisor star 1HomeAdvisor star 2HomeAdvisor star 3HomeAdvisor star 4HomeAdvisor star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Home Advisor.
Install or Replace an Asphalt Shingle Roof An extremely professional operation who did a quick, efficient and high quality job of my large new roof. I would recommend this company to anyone.
Posted on Angie's List Angie's List
michael melan profile picture
michael melan
930 days ago
AngiesList star 1AngiesList star 2AngiesList star 3AngiesList star 4AngiesList star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Angie's List.
Could not be happier with my new roof , did an awesome job , great craftsmanship Total professionals from start to finish . Just a pleasure to do business with . Made it so easy and with an active leak , they got me in asap .Couldn’t be happier! Great job guys , ty so much .
Posted on Home Advisor Home Advisor
JOHN B profile picture
JOHN B
1020 days ago
HomeAdvisor star 1HomeAdvisor star 2HomeAdvisor star 3HomeAdvisor star 4HomeAdvisor star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Home Advisor.
Install or Replace an Asphalt Shingle Roof Schoenherr worked from dawn to dusk to complete the project in a very timely fashion. They came in $1090 under budget, having finished the whole job within one work day and three hours. They provided photos of the roof halfway through the project and at completion ? I would have appreciated a few 'before' photos, too. They provided a group text so that everyone involved could communicate and stay looped in. My only other quibble is that the finance person always neglected to cc my wife on emails, even though the home-improvement loan is in her name. Finally, after wrapping up the project, Schoenherr put everything in both yards back in place and cleaned the site really well. Sometimes it's worth paying a little bit more for quality service and execution. Sometimes, it's not even that much more!
Posted on Home Advisor Home Advisor
JOHN B profile picture
JOHN B
1020 days ago
HomeAdvisor star 1HomeAdvisor star 2HomeAdvisor star 3HomeAdvisor star 4HomeAdvisor star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Home Advisor.
Install or Replace an Asphalt Shingle Roof Schoenherr worked from dawn to dusk to complete the project in a very timely fashion. They came in $1090 under budget, having finished the whole job within one work day and three hours. They provided photos of the roof halfway through the project and at completion ? I would have appreciated a few 'before' photos, too. They provided a group text so that everyone involved could communicate and stay looped in. My only other quibble is that the finance person always neglected to cc my wife on emails, even though the home-improvement loan is in her name. Finally, after wrapping up the project, Schoenherr put everything in both yards back in place and cleaned the site really well. Sometimes it's worth paying a little bit more for quality service and execution. Sometimes, it's not even that much more!
Posted on Home Advisor Home Advisor
Joe K profile picture
Joe K
1046 days ago
HomeAdvisor star 1HomeAdvisor star 2HomeAdvisor star 3HomeAdvisor star 4HomeAdvisor star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Home Advisor.
Install or Repair a Roof From beginning to end they follow up on everything and make sure the job is done correctly to their and the supplier's specifications. I honestly cannot say anything bad about our experience. They are very professional, honest, and hard working.
Residential Roofing

Before You Go...

Feel free to leave your contact information on our online form.  A consultation is always free, and it’s the first step towards finding an expert roofing solution from Schoenherr!

Schoenherr Roofing Service Truck Quality Customer Service in Michigan